June 24, 2026

Lancaster Review

Subscribe

The Best Ice Cream Shops In Lancaster, PA

The 2026 Lancaster Ice Cream Competition

Beginning June 18, you can cast your vote for the best ice cream shop in Lancaster County! Voting will continue through June, and we will announce the winner on July 2. 

Who has the best ice cream in Lancaster?(Required)
Your email is only used for validation to avoid multiple votes for one location. We will not email you without your permission.
Subscribe to The Lancaster Review?
Get the latest stories, restaurant reviews, and events delivered to your inbox.

Did we miss your favorite Lancaster County ice cream shop? Let us know.

Ice cream brings people together

Doug Ducey

Decades

438 N Queen St

College Treats

145 College Ave

Hinkle’s Restaurant

261 Locust St

Old Barn Creamery & Bakery

157 Martic Heights Dr

Coffee and Cream

101 N Front St

Udder Bliss Creamery

189 Ridgeview Rd S Suite 2

Boehringer’s Drive-In

3160 N Reading Rd

Lapp Valley Farms Ice Cream – Kitchen Kettle Village

3529 Old Philadelphia Pike

Son’s Ice Cream – East Petersburg

1991 Miller Rd

Son’s Ice Cream – Quarryville

319 W State St

Splits & Giggles

500 W Lemon St

Strasburg Creamery & General Store

1 W Main St

The Pretzel Hut

2224 Furnace Hills Pike

Little Dippers Ice Cream

432 W Main St

The Shack Restaurant & Mini Golf

662 S Oak St

Manheim Twin Kiss

309 S Main St

The Udder Choice

1812 W Main St

Maplehofe Dairy

799 Robert Fulton Hwy

Twisted Sisters Ice Cream & Handmade Chocolates

47 N Main St

Mezcla Ice Cream

318 S Duke St

Miesse Candies & Ice Cream Parlor

118 N Water St

Mulberry Thrill Outdoor Cold Brew and Ice Cream Cafe

100 W Market St Rear

Nikki’s Custard

1831 Oregon Pike

Oregon Dairy Milkhouse Ice Cream Shoppe

2900 Oregon Pike

Pine View Dairy

2225 New Danville Pike

Rolled Cold Creamery

2495 Lincoln Hwy E

Scoops Ice Cream & Grille

312 Primrose Ln

KC’s Italian Ice

617 W Orange St

32° Below Ice Cream Shop – Brickerville

10 E 28th Division Hwy

Lancaster Sweet Shoppe

141 N Duke St

32° Below Ice Cream Shop – Downtown Lititz

110 E Main St

Lapp Valley Farm

244 Mentzer Rd

Bird-in-Hand Bakery & Cafe

2715 Old Philadelphia Pike

Lapp Valley Farm Creamery & Cafe

4040 Old Philadelphia Pike

Bramble & Berry Real Fruit Ice Cream

559 W Chestnut St

Lickity Split Restaurant & Events

209 E Main St

Down on the Farm Creamery

509 May Post Office Rd

Down on the Farm Creamery – Choo Choo Barn

226 Gap Rd

Figments in Sprinkles

50 S Market St

Fox Meadows Creamery – Ephrata

2475 W Main St

Fox Meadows Creamery – Leola

193 E Main St

Freeze & Frizz

2250 New Holland Pike

GiGi’s Ice Cream Bar

2 S 2nd St

Good Life Ice Cream & Treats

2088 Fruitville Pike

Greco’s Italian Ices & Homemade Ice Cream – Hempfield

329 Main St Unit C

Greco’s Italian Ices & Homemade Ice Cream – Lititz

9 E Kleine Ln

Hayloft Ice Cream

95 S Groffdale Rd