The Best Ice Cream Shops in Lancaster, PA
Lancaster County is spoiled when it comes to ice cream. There are plenty of dairy farms that make and sell their own ice cream, as well as a plethora of local shops that sell a variety of delicious flavors. When it comes to finding great ice cream in Lancaster County, there is no shortage of excellent options.
The 2026 Lancaster Ice Cream Competition
5,300 Lancastrians voted for their favorite ice cream shop in Lancaster County. And the winner is… Gigi’s Ice Cream Bar! Fox Meadows, Lapp Valley, Pine View Dairy, and Down on the Farm round out the top five. Thank you to everyone who participated!
2026 Winner: Gigi's Ice Cream Bar
What locals say:
“Such an amazing small town, big flavor vibe!”
“Magical place for the kids and adults. The owner is beyond phenomenal and such a caring loving and fun human soul. Gina you rock!!!! “
“Gigi’s has ginormous ice cream sundaes, cones, and the vest vibe around! Small river town, locals hidden gem! Fresh homemade food as well “
“GiGis is a cornerstone of the small community it’s situated in. Great icecream, great prices, great service for the local community. “
Ice cream brings people together